Casa Mia Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

Reviews

• Adam B.

  star star star star star 6 June 2026

  The bomb! Award winning pizza for a reason. 3 cheese gorgonzola, litterly FTW! Service is friendly, and nice large vaulted ceilings I'm sure helps when it's busy. The food is fantastic, the environment is a bit  "mainstream, big business Italian wine bottles esk' " for me, but still nice. Don't be shy, and watch out easy to over eat here.

• Giovanna F.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 26 May 2026

  Update: Changing my review because I've had enough bad experiences with delivery or take out from here. The prices are high enough that it's not worth the hassle. Once with Uber Eats they left off an order. That was months ago. Uber fixed it. Then tonight I had my husband pick up an order and again they left out the flat bread that came with the Artichoke Ricotta Fonduta appetizer. Right. It sounded fancy that's why I ordered it except it wasn't fancy at all. It wasn't even artichoke. I was duped! This order was $40+ but we've spent over $100 dollars on other occasions. I am a seasoned customer.
  
  Getting dinner ready is hard enough with 2 young children (we order to go for a reason). When something is left out, it's not like we can just drop everything and go back.
  
  They didn't get 1 star because I did call and the lady on the phone was apologetic and I appreciated that. But overall for the value, quality of food, and consistency of food and service I will give it 2 stars.

• Shauntemarie G.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 21 May 2026

  Yo! If you love bland ass cafeteria food ... This is your place.
  First ... When we walked in the little blond girl was rude. She said sit anywhere with a scowl on her face. That was the first clue we shoulda walked out. Later she was slamming people's napkins down on their tables. Lol. Straight mess.
  The booth seats... Uncomfortable. U sink straight down so the table is at ur boobs.
  Food...
  Cesar salad tasted like... Nothing. There were no even garlic crutons.
  I had spaghetti with the garlic butter sauce and chicken. Lemme say... They don't use no garlic in this joint. They should rename the sauce bacon butter cheese sauce. Bland AF.
  My son got cheese pizza. Trash.
  Do yourself a favor and make your pasta at home.
  Too for the owners... Kick the girl with the attitude to the curb. Attitude + bland food = less repeat customers
  The server was nice tho..

• Mike M.

  star star star star star 17 May 2026

  Love Casa Mia!!  The pizza is there is amazing!  Been coming here for over 8 years and am never dissatisfied with the food. I can eat their fettuccine with extra garlic bread all day long!!!  Their staff has always been very friendly even when they are slammed with orders!  The spicy chicken Ceasar salad is also super yummy!

• S T.

  star star star star star 16 May 2026

  This is my husband and my "go to" pizza restaurant.  We have never been disappointed.  The wait staff are all very nice.  We have not tried their pasta, but one of these days I will.  We only go out for pizza every six weeks or so, and that's what we order.  I have heard that their pasta is good.  We have been going to Casa Mia in Lakewood for many, many years.